-  [WT]  [Home] [Manage]

[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [First 100 posts]
Posting mode: Reply
Name
Email
Subject   (reply to 1440)
Message
File
Password  (for post and file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 4000 KB.
  • Images greater than 200x200 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Currently 503 unique user posts. View catalog

  • Blotter updated: 2011-08-01 Show/Hide Show All

File 127380409968.jpg - (1.91MB , 805x4025 , Trainersjpeg.jpg )
1440 No. 1440
Zippie asked IRC to rate trainer art by series/gen. ITT, we do that.

Format: RBY > GSC > RS > E > FRLG > DP > P > HGSS > BW
Image is the trainers/series we're rating. It's jpeg, but if you really want the .png let me know.

If you want to make explanations for your choices, or go into more detail (like "Kris > Lyra > Gold > Ethan >" etc) because certain trainers deserve to be in different spots than their series or something, go ahead. Or you could even simplify it and combine trio games into one category.
Expand all images
>> No. 1441
okay i go in order of cuteness orz
HGSS>BW>P>RS>FRLG>DP>GSC>RBY
I am a sucker for kotone and the new girl
>> No. 1442
Right now,
Plat. > RBY > GSC > BW > E > RS > DP > HGSS > FRLG

Favourite art is Gold - it's like Red, but better. Runner ups are Platinum Lucas/Kouki and RS Brendan/Yuuki.
Least favourite is DP Lucas/Kouki. Least favourite girl is probably DP Dawn/Hikari. With FRLG, I think I'm just bitter that they're not the originals.
>> No. 1444
File 127381464516.png - (771.90KB , 2300x400 , mainchars.png )
1444
Wow, big coincidence. :O
^ I made this yesterday.
>> No. 1445
I hate to be That Guy, but I *hate* the new girl. She looks like a damn porn star.
>> No. 1446
FR/LG > Pt > B/W > E > G/S/C > R/B/Y > D/P > HG/SS > R/S

I love the remake of the FRLG characters, especially since both Red and Green still retained smug/cockiness attitudes (Leaf is just, there. But her hat practically carries her entire outfit). In Platinum, I really adore the winter coats the characters are wearing... Or maybe I'm a sucker for Autumn and Winter clothing in general. :P
>> No. 1448
File 127383675937.jpg - (116.05KB , 450x600 , 1273525533232.jpg )
1448
P > BW > GSC > FRLG > RBY > RS > HGSS > DP > E

Kotone is my favorite character, but her official art makes her look terrible. Fan depictions are much better, pic related.
Also, B/W characters are rockin'.
>> No. 1496
RS > E > BW > FRLG > HGSS > RBY > GSC > DP > P

RS wins namely because of May. Am liking the BW designs too. I think the DP/Pt designs are stupid and became even more stupid in Pt.
>> No. 1538
File 127415258848.png - (771.16KB , 850x1337 , sample_d51e42a44b7d1521dd0718775adc86e17e82f24a.png )
1538
>>1496
:(
>> No. 1539
>>1538
It seems like most of really like Platinum, which is pretty cool. I didn't warm up to their outfits for a while. But, once I made my Lucas cosplay, I really started to like them =] Plus winter is my favourite season.
>> No. 1540
File 127416040095.gif - (54.18KB , 320x240 , reaction dog.gif )
1540
>>1539
>I didn't warm up to their outfits for a while.
>> No. 1545
HGSS > BW > DP > FRLG > Plat. > RSE > GSC > RBY > Lyra


I really, REALLY love the new designs for Gold and Silver. "Lyra" is another story, but anyway. I'm probably mildly biased since I've actually made cosplayed these designs, too.

I'm also super excited about the new trainer designs. Black's design is a little "meh", but I think White's design is really cute. I like that they're older, too.

I prefer the DP designs to the Platinum designs based purely on the face that I'm a sucker for scarves, and they were longer/more flowy in the DP design. That, and I just really didn't like Lucas's winter design as much, though I like Barry's more...

The FRLG designs were just great, plain and simple.

RSE I'm lumping together, because I like Brendan's Emerald design more than his RS design, but I prefer May's RS design.

GSC and RBY are just kind of tied. The art wasn't as good back then (in my opinion), and I found the anatomy to be strangely off (tiny feet, overly long arms, etc.). GSC gets a slight edge though, because I still really, really like Kris's design.

Lyra's design made baby Jesus cry.
>> No. 1546
>I've actually made cosplayed these designs, too.

Uhg, grammar fail. "I've actually made cosplays for these designs" or "I've actually cosplayed these designs". Take your pick.
>> No. 1548
>>1545
Pics of your Pokémon-related cosplay(s) are mandatory. Feel free to shade out your face or whatever.
>> No. 1549
File 127422829325.png - (353.39KB , 580x385 , cosplay.png )
1549
>>1548

Uwaa... Well, here goes. Here we are, looking like a couple of retards...
>> No. 1551
File 127422848247.png - (269.98KB , 461x268 , rockets.png )
1551
Annnnd here I am with the massive Team Rocket group. I can't remember if this was before or after the guy cosplaying Giovanni was like, "You're fired from the family!"
>> No. 1555
>>1549
So, those are actually good! Except for Silver's pants. Hibiki/Ethan even has the pose right, and even has decent shoes. Awesome =]
What cons do you go to?
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts] [First 100 posts]

Delete post []
Password  
Report post
Reason